USASBE 2016, Entrepreneurship Everywhere?

San Diego at nightI recently attended my fourth USASBE conference in the last seven years. (USASBE = United States Association of Small Business and Entrepreneurship.) Despite the fact that USASBE awarded the Pave Program in Arts Entrepreneurship with its Excellence in Entrepreneurship Education Specialty Program Award last year, I always feel a bit like a fish out of water at this conference. About 80% of the attendees are entrepreneurship faculty from business schools. Nevertheless, there is a very active Arts Entrepreneurship special interest group (SIG).

A high point of the conference was a tour of some of San Diego’s infrastructure for San Diego Comic Art Museumarts and culture entrepreneurial activity organized by the SIG. Led by San Diego State’s Donna Conaty, we toured the recently refurbished Naval Training Center Arts District, which includes, among other facilities, dance spaces shared by three of the city’s dance companies and a museum of comic book art. It’s pretty wonderful that these decommissioned military faciliSan Diego Fab Labties have been made into arts and culture spaces. We also visited the developing “IDEA District” in downtown San Diego, anchored by the New College of Architecture and inclusive of a Fab Lab, among other spaces, both rehabbed and new construction.

A low point of the conference was the unfortunate keynote address by noted entrepreneurship scholar and educator Donald Kuratko. In an aggressive and at times belligerent tone, “Dr. K” indicted people (like me) who teach entrepreneurship within disciplines like engineering or the arts rather than in business schools. He accused such practices of diluting the study of entrepreneurship and went so far as to say that when entrepreneurship classes are taught in engineering (or, by inference, arts) schools, the student credit hour generation — and therefore the very revenue model of business schools — is threatened. He sounded defensive and angry; I don’t know that I have ever been made to feel so unwelcome. Ironic, given that the conference theme was “Entrepreneurship Everywhere.”

My positive feelings toward the organization were restored by the Bill Aulet’s plenary speech a few hours later in which he asserted that “entrepreneurship should not be taught in business schools if it is to be driven by innovation.” Aulet is from MIT’s Entrepreneurship Education Forum, which mission is “to promote entrepreneurship education by building a community that shares information and best practices, then integrates them and improves on them through open discussion…” While welcoming – even requiring – cross-campus entrepreneurship education, he also asserted that there is a lack of serious, rigorous scholarship in the field that creates or draws from good data sets. I have been saying similar about arts entrepreneurship.

Three years ago, when I first presented incubator research at USASBE’s San Francisco conference, the observed theme, or the methodology du jour, was Steven Blank’s lean launch and customer development process (he gave the keynote that year). My observation of the 2016 event is that there is a lot of interest in “design thinking” methodology as developed at IDEO and the Stanford Ultimately, these two “methods” have a lot in common – including empathic listening to the “customer,” or as I prefer to call people, “audience.” Fitting, then, that design thinking is the philosophic and pedagogic approach underlying a new degree being launched by ASU’s Herberger Institute for Design and the Arts: the Master of Arts in Creative Enterprise and Cultural Leadership.

About lindaessig

Linda Essig is Dean of the College of Arts & Letters at Cal State LA and principal/owner of Creative Infrastructure LLC. The opinions expressed on creativeinfrastructure are her own and not those of Cal State LA. You can follow her on twitter @LindaInPhoenix.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to USASBE 2016, Entrepreneurship Everywhere?

  1. Sun äitis says:

    it might be that what Jeff says is right. However, in that case Dr. Kuratko should have chosen a completely different way of delivering his speech. Like Linda, I also was frightened by the anger I sensed.

    (sunaitis is an old blog personality of mine I still use, when commenting on WordPress. In real life my name is Irmeli Pietilä, and I am a vocational teacher trainer at Haaga-Helia School of Vocational Teacher Education in Helsinki, Finland + a hobbyist entrepreneurship researcher whose phd was about hobbyist game development in the App Store)

  2. Jeff Hornsby says:

    I think you missed the key point of Dr. K’s message. He never said that having programs like yours is dilution. He said that we need to be careful not to dilute what entrepreneurship is in terms of venture creation. Too many programs do not include this piece and become no more than a creative problem solving or design thinking approach. I have his slides if you would like to review.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s